Nathan Cleary’s Possible Replacements: Who Could Step into the Halfback Role?
Nathan Cleary is undoubtedly one of the best players in the National Rugby League (NRL) today. A dynamic halfback for the Penrith Panthers and the New South Wales Blues, Cleary’s vision, skill, and leadership on the field have elevated him to a level of prominence rarely seen in the NRL. His ability to control games, direct attack, and guide his team through high-pressure situations has made him an indispensable player, not only for the Panthers but for the Australian national side as well.
However, rugby league, like any sport, faces uncertainty—whether through injury, form slumps, or the inevitable passing of time. Nathan Cleary, as great as he is, cannot play forever. While his dominance in the game seems set to continue for the foreseeable future, there will come a day when the NRL will need to identify a replacement—someone who can fill the massive void left by a player of Cleary’s caliber. This article explores potential candidates to replace Cleary, looking at the rising stars, established players, and emerging talents who could take on the iconic halfback role for both the Penrith Panthers and the New South Wales Blues in the years to come.
1. Jarome Luai – The Inside Man
While Nathan Cleary and Jarome Luai often combine as part of one of the NRL’s most lethal halves pairings, Luai could emerge as a natural successor should Cleary eventually move on. Luai is the creative force that complements Cleary’s more structured style of play. His flair, unpredictability, and dazzling footwork have seen him become one of the most exciting players in the competition.
While Luai typically plays as a five-eighth, many believe he has the potential to shift into the halfback role if needed. His rugby league IQ is high, and his vision on the field is often comparable to that of Cleary, especially when it comes to orchestrating attacking opportunities. Additionally, Luai’s leadership skills have been growing year on year, and he has shown a willingness to take on greater responsibility in clutch moments, such as during the Panthers’ crucial finals matches.
However, Luai’s ability to step into the halfback role depends largely on how Penrith’s coaching staff want to structure their team in the future. If Luai is to transition into the role of halfback, he may need to adjust his game slightly, becoming less focused on creating moments of individual brilliance and more on directing the team’s attack and kicking game, areas where Cleary has excelled. Still, there’s little doubt that Luai’s natural talent and growing leadership could make him a worthy candidate to eventually replace Cleary.
2. Jahream Bula – The Young Gun
One of the most exciting young talents to emerge in the NRL is Jahream Bula, a product of the Wests Tigers’ youth system. Bula has been widely touted as a future star and one of the most promising halfback prospects in the game. His ability to read the game and his composed kicking game make him an ideal candidate to replace someone like Cleary, who is known for his ability to manage field position with clinical precision.
Bula’s rapid development has already impressed many NRL pundits, and he’s a player who is showing the potential to lead teams at a high level. His footwork, speed, and creativity around the ruck have set him apart from other young halfbacks, and he has the composure to make important decisions under pressure, a key trait that Cleary possesses.
The question for Bula’s future lies in his ability to develop a kicking game on par with Cleary’s. Nathan Cleary’s kicking has been a standout feature of his play, with his ability to control territory, kick for touch, and put up pinpoint grubbers in attack being key to his dominance. Bula has shown promise in this area, but it remains to be seen if he can truly replicate Cleary’s precision and consistency. If he can, there’s every chance that Bula could emerge as a successor in the halfback position.
3. Dylan Brown – A Playmaker with a Strong Defensive Edge
Dylan Brown has long been seen as one of the most talented young halfbacks in the NRL. A key player for the Parramatta Eels, Brown has the playmaking ability, agility, and vision that many consider to be the hallmarks of a future star at the halfback position. While Brown is typically a five-eighth, his ability to play both halves positions would give him an edge when it comes to potentially filling Cleary’s shoes.
Brown has already demonstrated his exceptional vision and creativity in attack. His combination of quick footwork, evasive running, and exceptional passing game makes him a threat in the middle of the field, and his work with Mitchell Moses in the halves has been a defining feature of Parramatta’s success. Brown’s ability to kick and control the game at a high level is another factor that could see him rise into the halfback role.
What sets Brown apart is his defensive prowess. While many playmakers are known for their attacking skills, Brown’s defense is often overlooked, yet it is an area where he excels. His tackling technique and commitment to putting in hard defensive work would make him a valuable asset to any team, and his work ethic would go a long way in making him a formidable replacement for Cleary.
4. Sam Walker – The Rising Star
Sam Walker of the Sydney Roosters is another player who could be a natural successor to Nathan Cleary. A player who burst onto the scene with his exceptional kicking game and precision as a teenager, Walker is a prodigious talent in the halves. His vision, ball-handling skills, and ability to orchestrate attacking moves with sharp, calculated decisions have made him one of the most exciting young players in the competition.
What sets Walker apart is his calm demeanor and maturity beyond his years. He’s a player who takes control of the game from the first whistle, showing composure and decision-making that belies his age. His kicking game, while still developing, has already shown signs of becoming one of the best in the competition, with long-range field goals, pinpoint bombs, and clever chip kicks. If Walker can continue to develop his physicality and defensive game, he has the potential to become a dominant halfback at the NRL level and could one day replace Cleary both at the Panthers and as a representative player for New South Wales.
5. Luke Brooks – The Veteran Option
Luke Brooks, long considered one of the NRL’s top halfbacks, has been a fixture for the Wests Tigers for many years. While his career has had its ups and downs, Brooks is still regarded as one of the more talented playmakers in the league. His combination of tactical kicking, game management, and passing ability make him a potential option for teams looking to replace a player like Nathan Cleary.
Brooks’ experience at the NRL level is invaluable, and while his form has fluctuated at times, his potential to lead and guide a team remains high. With the right system and support around him, Brooks could still prove himself as a worthy successor in the halfback position. Though it’s unlikely he’ll be seen as the “next Cleary,” his pedigree and skill set mean he cannot be ruled out, especially for a veteran team looking for an experienced head in the halves.
Conclusion: Who Will Replace Cleary?
Nathan Cleary’s influence on the game cannot be overstated, and replacing him as a halfback for both the Penrith Panthers and the New South Wales Blues will be a monumental task. While there are many young players coming through the ranks, few possess the complete skill set and mentality that Cleary has shown throughout his career. However, the future of the halfback position is bright, with players like Jarome Luai, Jahream Bula, Dylan Brown, Sam Walker, and Luke Brooks all showing the potential to fill the void in the coming years.
While Cleary’s replacement might not be one player alone, the next generation of halfbacks will need to exhibit the same combination of leadership, vision, and composure that has defined Cleary’s career. As time passes, the NRL will see new stars emerge who will one day take on the mantle of leading teams to victory, but for now, Nathan Cleary’s reign as one of the game’s premier playmakers remains unchallenged.
Be the first to comment