Penrith Panthers 2025 NRL season scouting report: Best 17, every player’s contract status, rookie watch

The losses of Jarome Luai and James Fisher-Harris are huge blows for Penrith, who face an uphill battle to defend their title. FATIMA KDOUH analyses the challenges facing the champions, rookies to watch and more.

 

Penrith Panthers 2025 NRL Season Scouting Report: Best 17, Contract Status, and Rookie Watch

As the Penrith Panthers gear up for the 2025 NRL season, the club is poised to continue their reign of dominance in Australian rugby league. Having secured three consecutive premierships between 2021 and 2023, Penrith enters the new season with a core group of established stars, promising rookies, and a strong coaching staff led by Ivan Cleary. However, with several key players’ contract statuses in flux, the Panthers will need to balance the pursuit of success in the short term with planning for the long-term future.

Best 17 for the 2025 NRL Season

The Penrith Panthers’ best 17 for the 2025 season will see a blend of experience and youthful energy, continuing the club’s balanced approach. With many players remaining under contract for multiple years, the club’s future looks bright.

1. Dylan Edwards (Fullback) Edwards has been one of the standout fullbacks in the NRL over the past few seasons, offering a perfect mix of toughness, agility, and a strong defensive game. His ability to set the tone with early carries and his leadership in the backline will be crucial for the Panthers in 2025.

2. Brian To’o (Left Wing) One of the most reliable wingers in the competition, To’o is a powerhouse in both attack and defense. His strong carries from the backfield and consistent try-scoring ability make him one of Penrith’s most dangerous players.

3. Stephen Crichton (Left Centre) Although Crichton has moved on to Canterbury, Penrith will need to find a replacement to partner up with To’o. Several young players will be vying for this spot, but Crichton’s combination with To’o in previous seasons made it one of the most dominant partnerships in the NRL.

4. Justin Olam (Right Centre) Penrith will be relying on a blend of experienced talent and young blood for this right centre role in 2025. Olam, who has been a stalwart of Melbourne Storm’s defense, could add extra toughness and leadership to the Panthers’ backline if they manage to secure his services in the off-season.

5. Taylor May (Right Wing) The dynamic winger has continued to impress with his agility and speed. May has become a key player in Penrith’s backline and his ability to finish off set plays will be crucial for the Panthers’ attacking structure.

6. Jarome Luai (Five-Eighth) The talented playmaker has been a vital part of the Panthers’ success over the past few years, bringing flair, creativity, and a never-say-die attitude. Luai’s ability to break down defenses with his sharp footwork and unpredictable play will be pivotal for Penrith in 2025.

7. Nathan Cleary (Halfback) Arguably one of the best halfbacks in the game, Nathan Cleary’s leadership, kicking game, and playmaking ability are second to none. Cleary’s control of the game and tactical kicking will continue to guide Penrith’s attacking movements, making him a central figure in the club’s 2025 aspirations.

8. James Fisher-Harris (Prop) Fisher-Harris has been one of the top props in the NRL for several years, known for his hard, relentless runs and solid defense. He will continue to set the platform for the Panthers’ forwards in 2025.

9. Moses Leota (Prop) A dependable forward who has a knack for making hard meters and laying a solid foundation for his team. Leota’s experience will be vital in helping the Panthers maintain forward momentum in 2025.

10. Viliame Kikau (Second Row) Although Kikau moved to the Bulldogs, Penrith still has some strong back-row options. The likes of J’maine Hopgood and Luke Garner will aim to fill this gap, bringing similar aggression, speed, and versatility to the pack.

11. Isaah Yeo (Lock) Yeo’s leadership and work rate make him one of the NRL’s most respected players. A key figure in both attack and defense, Yeo’s defensive organization and offloading skills will remain critical to Penrith’s success.

12. Liam Martin (Second Row) Martin’s tireless work ethic, defensive capabilities, and energy make him a vital part of the Penrith pack. He brings aggression and intensity to the team, often being a key figure in the middle of the park during critical moments.

13. Apisai Koroisau (Hooker) Koroisau’s service from dummy-half, coupled with his ability to control the ruck and create space for his forwards, is invaluable to the Panthers. His presence in the 9 jersey is crucial for their game plan.

14. Spencer Leniu (Bench) Leniu has been an impressive player off the bench in recent years, offering speed and aggression when needed. His impact in the middle will be essential in creating momentum for Penrith throughout the 2025 season.

15. Tevita Pangai Junior (Bench) Pangai Junior’s raw power and destructive ball-carrying ability will add a new dimension to Penrith’s forward pack. His physicality could be the difference-maker when the team needs to change the tempo of the game.

16. Soni Luke (Bench) Luke, a talented hooker, provides depth to the Panthers’ spine. His agility and intelligence around the ruck can create quick plays and provide relief when Koroisau is off the field.

17. J’maine Hopgood (Bench) Hopgood, a promising young talent, will add fresh legs and aggression to the forward pack. His versatility in the back row or as a middle forward makes him a valuable asset for Penrith in 2025.

Contract Status

The Panthers are in a relatively strong position regarding player contracts. However, several players will enter the 2025 season with contract decisions to be made. Key players like Nathan Cleary, who is under contract until 2027, and Dylan Edwards, with his extension through 2026, ensure that the spine remains stable for several more years. However, with players like Jarome Luai and Liam Martin coming off contracts in the next couple of seasons, Penrith’s management will have to carefully consider how to retain their stars while also managing their salary cap. The club’s ability to balance this will be a major factor in sustaining their premiership ambitions.

Rookie Watch: Rising Stars

Penrith’s development system continues to produce top-tier talent, and there are several rookies to keep an eye on in 2025:

1. J’Maine Hopgood While already part of the senior squad, Hopgood’s development is worth watching. A standout in the NSW Cup, Hopgood could make a huge impact in the NRL in 2025, bringing a mix of grit, skill, and energy to Penrith’s forward pack.

2. Jack Cole Cole is another young player on the radar for Penrith in 2025. His performances in junior leagues and pre-season trials will determine his role in the first-grade squad.

3. Zac Croker Croker is a highly rated young center who could fill the void left by Stephen Crichton. His strong defensive attributes and attacking flair make him an exciting prospect for the Panthers’ backline.

Conclusion

The Penrith Panthers’ 2025 NRL season looks promising, with a core group of experienced players, strong new signings, and talented young stars. While contract management will be critical in maintaining a championship-contending team, the club’s depth and resilience in both attack and defense will continue to make them a force to be reckoned with. With Ivan Cleary at the helm, Penrith is well-positioned to extend its dominance in the NRL for years to come.